Attention (some) Manchester United fans: all racial stereotyping is racist | Marina Hyde


The song about Romelu Lukaku’s penis is not just ‘banter’ because the trouble with supposedly positive stereotypes is that they tend to be accompanied in the minds of those who hold them by distinctly less complimentary ones

Why is it racist to say Jews are careful with their money? Why is it racist to say Asians are good at maths? Why is it racist to say black men have 24-inch penises? Guys, these are compliments! Your lot are never satisfied, are they?

And so to some Manchester United fans’ chants about their striker Romelu Lukaku, which a totally encouraging number of people simply cannot see are racist. To be super-clear (and apologies to those who realised this in 1964 or whenever): any assumption about someone made solely on the basis of that person’s race is racist. It may also be banter – but it is racist banter. And if anyone’s still struggling with the logical underpinnings of that incredibly simple rule of thumb, we’ll be diving deeper into why in a minute.

Related: David Squires on … Harry Redknapp and football managers' early-season troubles

What’s the likelihood the only stereotype those people hold about black people is that they have enormous penises? Zero

Related: Rio Ferdinand confirms move into boxing: 'It’s a challenge I’m not taking lightly'

Continue reading...