The Best MLB Teams Of All-Time, According To Elo

May 09, 2016

One hundred and 10 years ago, the Chicago Cubs ended the regular season with a 116-36 record. That .763 winning percentage is the best in modern baseball history by a comfortable margin, but the Cubs went on to drop the World Series to the White Sox in six games. Might they still be the greatest team in baseball history?

We recently calculated historical Elo ratings for every team after every game as part of our Complete History Of MLB interactive graphic. (We’ve done the same for the NBA and NFL.) Elo ratings are one of our preferred metrics at FiveThirtyEight, because their simple inputs make them useful for comparing the relative strengths of teams across the entire history of a league. We can also use Elo to calculate season ratings for every MLB team since 1903, when the first modern World Series was played.¹¹ We arrived at an overall season rating — what the table below calls “composite” Elo — by blending each team’s peak, average and final Elo for each season. This lets us take into account a team’s highest level of performance, its sustained performance throughout the season and, broadly, how well it did in the postseason.¹²

So who comes out on top? The 1906 Cubs have the highest peak Elo, but because of their World Series loss, they rate as the second-best team since 1903, behind the 1939 New York Yankees. We ranked all 2,374 team-seasons from 1903 to 2015 — you can explore them below:

Our Elo ratings find that the league was a bit more top-heavy in its earlier decades. If you scan through the top of the list, you’ll notice that most of the best seasons since 1903 happened more than 50 years ago — in fact, 71 of the 100 best seasons fall before 1960. The New York Yankees’ insane dominance in the 1920s, ’30s, ’40s and ’50s is responsible for a lot of this imbalance. Twenty-five of the 100 best seasons are Yankees seasons from those decades:

After the Yankees dynasty declined, MLB’s best teams started to be a lot less good. The 1960s were understandably weak — with just two teams in the Elo top 100 — because MLB expanded by eight teams during this span. The 1980s don’t have the same excuse, and the decade’s best squad — the 1986 Mets — rates as only the 62nd-best team ever. The first six seasons of the 2010s were similarly middling; of the teams from those years, the 2011 Phillies rank the highest on the all-time list, at No. 76.

Although that Philadelphia team lost in the division series, it still rates as the best Phillies squad in history. Here’s every franchise’s best team ever:

Every MLB franchise’s best season, 1903-2015
	FRANCH.	TEAM		COMP. ELO	WON WS?	RANK AMONG BEST TEAMS EVER
–	NYY	1939	New York Yankees	1623		1
–	CHC	1906	Chicago Cubs	1620		2
–	PIT	1909	Pittsburgh Pirates	1609		4
–	OAK	1911	Philadelphia Athletics	1607		7
–	STL	1942	St. Louis Cardinals	1605		8
–	SF	1905	New York Giants	1601		13
–	BAL	1970	Baltimore Orioles	1600		19
–	CIN	1976	Cincinnati Reds	1595		23
–	CLE	1954	Cleveland Indians	1594		24
–	SEA	2001	Seattle Mariners	1590		34
–	LAD	1953	Brooklyn Dodgers	1586		40
–	ATL	1998	Atlanta Braves	1586		42
–	DET	1935	Detroit Tigers	1585		43
–	BOS	1912	Boston Red Sox	1584		46
–	NYM	1986	New York Mets	1580		62
–	CHW	1917	Chicago White Sox	1579		68
–	MIN	1933	Washington Senators	1577		74
–	PHI	2011	Philadelphia Phillies	1577		76
–	LAA	2002	Anaheim Angels	1576		81
–	HOU	1998	Houston Astros	1572		110
–	TEX	2011	Texas Rangers	1568		141
–	TOR	2015	Toronto Blue Jays	1565		161
–	ARI	2002	Arizona Diamondbacks	1564		166
–	WSH	1994	Montreal Expos	1561	*	208
–	KC	1977	Kansas City Royals	1560		213
–	TB	2012	Tampa Bay Rays	1558		237
–	MIL	1982	Milwaukee Brewers	1558		246
–	SD	1998	San Diego Padres	1543		480
–	COL	2007	Colorado Rockies	1537		596
–	MIA	2003	Florida Marlins	1537		601

The 1939 Yankees and 1906 Cubs are in a league of their own, more than 10 Elo points ahead of the other franchises. The Marlins have only been around since 1993, but it’s still sort of sad that their best team ever (World Series champions no less!) is just the 601st-best team ever. The Colorado Rockies, a franchise that was also born in 1993, are about as sad, but without the World Series rings. The San Diego Padres have had a much longer commitment to mediocrity; the franchise’s best team in its 47 seasons of existence comes in at No. 480. Fans of the Braves, Dodgers, Red Sox, Tigers, White Sox, Twins and Phillies may also be disappointed by their team’s position in this list. All seven franchises go back to 1903, but none of their teams in the last 113 seasons have come close to cracking the top 25.

But great seasons aren’t the only way to be an exceptional baseball team. Here’s every MLB franchise’s worst squad ever:

Every MLB franchise’s worst season, 1903-2015
	FRANCH.	TEAM		COMP. ELO	RANK AMONG WORST TEAMS EVER
–	MIN	1904	Washington Senators	1387	1
–	DET	2003	Detroit Tigers	1397	2
–	NYM	1962	New York Mets	1398	3
–	PHI	1942	Philadelphia Phillies	1400	4
–	OAK	1916	Philadelphia Athletics	1402	5
–	ATL	1911	Boston Rustlers	1414	9
–	BOS	1932	Boston Red Sox	1414	12
–	BAL	1911	St. Louis Browns	1417	15
–	PIT	1953	Pittsburgh Pirates	1418	19
–	TOR	1979	Toronto Blue Jays	1419	22
–	SD	1969	San Diego Padres	1419	23
–	WSH	1969	Montreal Expos	1421	25
–	HOU	2013	Houston Astros	1425	35
–	SEA	1978	Seattle Mariners	1429	40
–	TEX	1973	Texas Rangers	1431	44
–	LAD	1905	Brooklyn Superbas	1431	46
–	STL	1908	St. Louis Cardinals	1432	51
–	CHW	1932	Chicago White Sox	1435	61
–	CIN	1934	Cincinnati Reds	1436	69
–	KC	2005	Kansas City Royals	1437	71
–	CHC	1962	Chicago Cubs	1441	94
–	TB	2002	Tampa Bay Devil Rays	1442	96
–	MIL	1969	Seattle Pilots	1443	103
–	COL	1993	Colorado Rockies	1444	105
–	NYY	1908	New York Highlanders	1449	136
–	ARI	2004	Arizona Diamondbacks	1449	143
–	MIA	1993	Florida Marlins	1449	146
–	CLE	1915	Cleveland Indians	1451	156
–	SF	1985	San Francisco Giants	1461	251
–	LAA	1969	California Angels	1464	279

The 2003 Detroit Tigers lost 119 games, winning five of their last six to avoid the 120-loss modern record set by the 1962 Mets in their first season as a franchise. Elo isn’t fooled, though — the 2003 Tigers had a slightly worse run differential than the 1962 Mets and have a slightly lower rating here. The 1904 Washington Senators, now the Twins, were even more terrible according to Elo, going 38-113 (the equivalent of a 121-loss modern 162-game season). Angels fans probably don’t look back on the 91-loss 1969 season too fondly, but, compared with the other franchises’ lousiest seasons ever, it’s not a bad low point, ranking just 279th-worst.

So what will come in 2016? The Atlanta Braves and Cincinnati Reds have had a rough start and could make a run at new Elo lows for their franchises. But the real team to watch is the Chicago Cubs, who have started the season at 24-6 with an incredible +102 run differential. It’s a hard pace to keep up, but if they do, the Cubs could make a run at becoming one of the greatest teams of all time.

See the complete history of every MLB team.

Check out our latest MLB predictions.

Tags: MLB New York Yankees